Alt: “How to Tell If a Creative Idea Is Worth Finishing (And When to Let It Go)”

Not every song I’ve started has needed to be finished. Some of them I was glad I didn’t. A few I wish I’d abandoned earlier and got some of that creative time back.

There’s a version of creative advice that says: always finish what you start. Push through. Finish the draft, finish the song, finish the painting. And yes, there is a good reason for that. Finishing things builds discipline and skill in a way that giving up repeatedly does not.

But I don’t think it’s the full picture.

Because some ideas aren’t worth finishing. Some are experiments that served their purpose. Some are warm-ups that taught you something and don’t need to go any further. And some, if you’re honest with yourself, were never quite right from the start.

The question is: how do you tell the difference?

Not Finishing Isn’t Always Giving Up

We tend to treat unfinished work as some sort of moral failure. Like if you abandon a project, you’ve let yourself down, your family, your country, your very human reason to be!

But abandonment and quitting aren’t the same thing when it comes to creativity and our art. Seth Godin, in The Dip, draws a useful distinction between the Dip and the Cul-de-Sac. The Dip is the hard stretch that separates people who push through from people who stop short of something genuinely worthwhile. You want to push through the Dip.

The Cul-de-Sac is different. It’s the road that leads nowhere. It looks like progress, it feels like effort, but no amount of pushing is going to get you where you want to go. The smart move is to recognise it early and stop.

Some creative ideas are Dips. They’re hard because they’re worth doing. Some are Cul-de-Sacs. They’re hard because they’re not going anywhere. Art should not be an impasse.

The problem is, when we’re in the middle of creating something, we often can’t tell which is which.

What to Look For Early

The earlier you evaluate, the less time and effort you lose. And there are a few things worth paying attention to before you’re too deep in.

Energy. Does the idea still pull at you? Not in a comfortable, familiar way… in the way where you find yourself thinking about it when you’re not working on it, ideas continue to flow even when you’re not at the desk, easel, or holding the guitar. A song that’s worth finishing tends to nag at you. An idea that’s run its course tends to just sit there.

Momentum. Are you making progress, even slow progress? Or are you stuck in the same place every time you come back to it? Genuine difficulty often feels like resistance with direction. A bad fit tends to feel like circular effort: lots of motion, same spot.

Honest resonance. If you played this for, or shared your art with, someone right now, how would you feel? Not “would it be good enough” but: does it say something true? Does it feel like yours?

Austin Kleon wrote about “relocating your darlings” rather than killing them. The idea that if a line or an element feels precious but doesn’t fit, you don’t have to scrap it. You move it somewhere it can breathe. That’s a useful reframe for half-finished ideas too: a piece that’s stalling might not be a dead end; it might just be in the wrong project. A melody may fit in another harmony, a character in a different plot or an image in a different composition.

Making the Call

There’s research that suggests we’re wired to stay in things longer than we should. Psychologists call it the sunk cost fallacy: the more we’ve already invested, the harder it is to stop, even when stopping is the right move. Time spent, effort made, the version of the piece we’ve imagined, all of these things make walking away feel like loss.

But time you put into a Cul-de-Sac is time you’re not putting into something that has genuine pull. And unfinished projects that have lost their energy don’t just sit quietly. They take up mental space. They create guilt. They crowd out the ideas that might actually want to go somewhere. They are the mountain pile obscuring your creative vision.

A few questions I’ve found useful:

• If I started this from scratch today, would I?
• Am I still curious about where this is going, or am I just trying to resolve it?
• Is the difficulty coming from the work being hard, or from the idea not quite working?

None of these questions will give you a definitive answer. But they’ll often give you a feeling. And that feeling is usually worth listening to.

Some ideas are finished when they’re done. Others are finished when they’ve taught you what they had to teach. Both are valid outcomes. The goal isn’t to finish everything. It’s to finish the things that deserve it.

---

Thank you for reading this post. Please share your thoughts in the comment section below.
namaste
d
xox

If you enjoyed this post please support my writing by making a donation of any amount.

Sign up for my (ir)regular newsletter to keep up to date with my creative adventures, including special offers, and join me on Instagram | YouTube | Twitter | Pinterest